Hmmm, I enjoyed Depp's performance in Pirates.

Oh, me too. I think his performance was quite entertaining - but just not oscar-worthy. Take away the pirate garb and throw on an old-west costume and his character would have been Doc Holliday from Tombstone. Back when Val Kilmer did that performance it was original. I felt mostly like Johnny Depp's performance was somewhat of an anachronism.

- trs