Definitely turn her in. She would not have given a rats ass had she not been caught and would probably do the same thing again. I think you're giving her leeway (sp?) because its a rental, but I think thats a mute point. She didn't know it was a rental, it could have been her next door neighbors. I would at the very least give her a hard time. IMHO she got off waaaaaaay too easy for something so serious.